A chemical ‘Goldilocks zone’ may limit which planets can host life

A chemical ‘Goldilocks zone’ may limit which planets can host life Skip to content Subscribe today Every print subscription comes with full digital access Subscribe Now Menu All Topics Health Humans Anthropology Health & Medicine Archaeology Psychology View All Life Animals Plants Ecosystems Paleontology Neuroscience Genetics Microbes View All Earth Agriculture Climate Oceans Environment View All Physics Materials Science Quantum Physics Particle Physics View All Space Astronomy Planetary Science Cosmology View All Magazine Menu All Stories Multimedia Reviews Puzzles Collections Educator Portal Century of Science Unsung characters Coronavirus Outbreak Newsletters Investors Lab About SN Explores Our Store SIGN IN Donate Home INDEPENDENT JOURNALISM SINCE 1921 SIGN IN Search Open search Close search Home INDEPENDENT JOURNALISM SINCE 1921 All Topics Earth Agriculture Climate Oceans Environment Humans Anthropology Health & Medicine Archaeology Psychology Life Animals Plants Ecosystems Paleontology Neuroscience Genetics Microbes Physics Materials Science Quantum Physics Particle Physics Space Astronomy Planetary Science Cosmology Tech Computing Artificial Intelligence Chemistry Math Science & Society All Topics Health Humans Humans Anthropology Health & Medicine Archaeology Psychology Recent posts in Humans Neuroscience The right sounds may turn sleep into a problem-solving tool By Bethany BrookshireMarch 3, 2026 Health & Medicine Over 40? Your rotator cuff probably looks a little rough By Meghan RosenMarch 3, 2026 Health & Medicine Simulations of your gut may predict which probiotics will stick By Nora BradfordMarch 2, 2026 Life Life Animals Plants Ecosystems Paleontology Neuroscience Genetics Microbes Recent posts in Life Animals Cockroaches that eat each other’s wings turn into a fierce fighting force By Bethany BrookshireMarch 3, 2026 Neuroscience The right sounds may turn sleep into a problem-solving tool By Bethany BrookshireMarch 3, 2026 Anthropology The ancient human ancestor ‘Little Foot’ gets a new face By Jay BennettMarch 2, 2026 Earth Earth Agriculture Climate Oceans Environment Recent posts in Earth Climate Hundreds of studies have missed how much the oceans are rising By Nikk Ogasa4 hours ago Climate Take it from the Olympics, slushy winter sports may be the new normal By Natasha VizcarraFebruary 27, 2026 Animals Climate change could threaten monarch mass migration By Erin Garcia de JesúsFebruary 25, 2026 Physics Physics Materials Science Quantum Physics Particle Physics Recent posts in Physics Physics Here’s why sneakers squeak on the basketball court By Emily ConoverFebruary 25, 2026 Animals Intricate silk helps net-casting spiders ensnare prey in webs By Emily ConoverFebruary 24, 2026 Physics Physicists dream up ‘spacetime quasicrystals’ that could underpin the universe By Emily ConoverFebruary 17, 2026 Space Space Astronomy Planetary Science Cosmology Recent posts in Space Planetary Science A Titan collision may link Saturn’s tilt, its moon Hyperion and its rings By Lisa Grossman2 hours ago Planetary Science A chemical ‘Goldilocks zone’ may limit which planets can host life By Katherine Kornei6 hours ago Space NASA scraps its 2027 moon landing, adds two missions in 2028 By Lisa GrossmanFebruary 27, 2026 News Planetary Science A chemical ‘Goldilocks zone’ may limit which planets can host life New research highlights a narrow chemical balance needed to preserve key nutrients Finding life elsewhere in the universe might require considering more than one “Goldilocks zone.” Elen11/iStock/Getty Images Plus By Katherine Kornei 6 hours ago Share this:Share Share via email (Opens in new window) Email Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit Share on X (Opens in new window) X Print (Opens in new window) Print Astronomers’ favorite fable just got a new twist. The “Goldilocks zone” — the region of space not too close and not too far from a star where liquid water could exist on a planet’s surface — now has a chemical equivalent. Researchers have found that a narrow range of planetary conditions are necessary to ensure the availability of bioessential nutrients like phosphorus and nitrogen. The team simulated tens of thousands of exoplanets and found that fewer than 1 in 10 had Earthlike abundances of phosphorus and nitrogen. The results might help explain why life hasn’t yet been found beyond our home planet, planetary scientist Craig Walton and colleagues report February 9 in Nature Astronomy. Sign up for our newsletter We summarize the week's scientific breakthroughs every Thursday. Water is important for planetary habitability, but it’s not everything, says Walton, of the University of Cambridge. “You need nutrients.” In particular, elements such as phosphorus and nitrogen are crucial to assembling cell walls, encoding genetic information and building proteins, among other roles. Imagining life without these nutrients is a stretch, Walton says. “It’s really hard to come up with what an alternative biology would look like.” But even a watery planet bestowed with phosphorus and nitrogen from its birth environment doesn’t get a scientific green light to host life. That’s because these elements can sink into the core of a forming planet. And unlike a planet’s mantle, which regularly exchanges material with the surface via volcanism, the core is isolated. Any phosphorus or nitrogen that makes its way there is of no use to life living on the surface, says Sebastiaan Krijt, an astrophysicist at the University of Exeter in England, who was not involved in the research. “It’s completely inaccessible to life.” Whether or not phosphorus and nitrogen sink into the core depends on the availability of reactable oxygen in the mantle. “Oxygen is really what’s key,” says Laura Rogers, an astronomer at NOIRLab in Tucson, Ariz. The oxygen abundance determines how phosphorus and nitrogen react with iron, which tends to sink deeper and deeper into a forming planet over time. When there’s lots of oxygen around, phosphorus doesn’t bind to iron and therefore tends to remain in the mantle; nitrogen, on the other hand, will bind to iron and sink into the core. Low levels of oxygen result in the opposite pattern — less phosphorus in the mantle and more nitrogen. That’s a push-pull situation, Walton says. “You’re gaining one, you’re losing another.” Walton, Rogers and their team surmised there must be a “chemical Goldilocks zone” — a sweet spot of oxygen abundance that results in Earthlike quantities of both phosphorus and nitrogen in a planet’s mantle. To investigate that idea, they simulated exoplanets with initial phosphorus and nitrogen quantities based on the observed chemistry of several thousand nearby stars and a range of reactable oxygen levels drawn from prior theoretical work. Less than 10 percent of thos